top of page

Can Small-Scale Shrimp Farming Be Sustainable? New Research Points the Way Forward

Writer's picture: yxtungyxtung

In coastal villages across Asia, small-scale shrimp farmers face a daily balancing act: how to produce enough shrimp to make a living while protecting the environment their livelihoods depend on. It's not an easy task, but recent research suggests there might be a way forward.



The Big Picture: Small Farms, Big Impact


Picture this: a typical shrimp farm in India or Vietnam, barely larger than a football field. These small farms – usually less than 2 hectares – produce most of Asia's shrimp exports. But they face mounting challenges, from disease outbreaks to environmental concerns (Sivaraman et al., 2019).


"The rapid expansion of producing areas has resulted in the loss of mangrove forests that threatens peoples' livelihoods and the ecosystem," notes Nguyen and colleagues (2019) in their comprehensive review of Vietnam's shrimp sector. These environmental impacts aren't just bad for nature – they're threatening the very future of shrimp farming itself.


Better Practices: Easier Said Than Done


So what's the solution? One approach is Better Management Practices (BMPs) – essentially a playbook for sustainable shrimp farming. New research from India's shrimp heartland of Andhra Pradesh shows some interesting patterns in how farmers adopt these practices (Sivaraman et al., 2019):


  • The basics? No problem. Nearly all farmers (95.7%) follow good pond preparation practices

  • The complex stuff? That's harder. Only about a third implement proper biosecurity measures

  • The paperwork? That's the toughest. Less than 30% maintain proper farm management records


Why the big differences? It comes down to a mix of factors: education, experience, and – you guessed it – money. "Adopting all the recommended BMPs in full would decrease the net returns from each crop by 16.6%," the researchers found. That's a tough pill to swallow for farmers operating on thin margins.



Super-Intensive: The Next Big Thing?


Meanwhile, in Vietnam, researchers are exploring another approach: super-intensive farming. Think of it as the difference between traditional farming and vertical farming – doing more with less space.


The results are promising. According to Nguyen et al. (2019), super-intensive systems can:

- Use 90% less land than traditional methods

- Save significantly on energy costs

- Better control disease outbreaks


But there's a catch – and it's a big one. These systems need serious capital investment and technical know-how. Not exactly easy for small farmers to access.



Finding Middle Ground


So what's the answer? Both research teams point to a hybrid approach that combines:


1. Smart Technology: Using biofloc systems and better disease management

2. Clever Cooperation: Getting small farmers to work together

3. Strong Support: Both from government and financial institutions


"The government of Vietnam has promoted shrimp farming to support rural economic development," notes Nguyen et al. (2019). But promotion isn't enough – farmers need practical support to make sustainable practices work.


What's Next?


The future of sustainable shrimp farming likely lies in finding the sweet spot between traditional practices and modern technology. As Sivaraman et al. (2019) suggest, this might mean:


- Forming farmer cooperatives to share resources and knowledge

- Developing better financing options for small farmers

- Creating stronger links between small farmers and larger producers



The Bottom Line


Can small-scale shrimp farming be sustainable? The research suggests yes – but only with the right mix of practices, policies, and support. It's not just about telling farmers to do better; it's about making "better" possible.


For consumers, this means understanding that sustainable shrimp isn't just about what happens in the pond – it's about supporting systems that help small farmers succeed sustainably.


References


Nguyen, T. A. T., Nguyen, K. A. T., & Jolly, C. (2019). Is Super-Intensification the Solution to Shrimp Production and Export Sustainability? Sustainability, 11(19), 5277.


Sivaraman, I., Krishnan, M., & Radhakrishnan, K. (2019). Better Management Practices for Sustainable Small-scale Shrimp Farming. Journal of Cleaner Production.


*Want to learn more about sustainable seafood? Follow our blog for regular updates on aquaculture innovation and environmental sustainability.*

Comments


bottom of page